top of page
Search

Loving Children Is the Beginning, Not the Qualification: A Great Nanny Understands Developmentally Appropriate Practices

Writer: Cera Parrino
Cera Parrino
Nov 13
7 min read

A young woman smiling at a sleeping baby.

Why being wonderful with children and understanding child development aren't always the same thing—and why your child deserves both.

 

We've all met someone who is wonderful with children. They're warm, patient, playful, and have a natural ability to connect. Children gravitate toward them, and parents immediately feel at ease. Those qualities are essential to providing nurturing childcare.

 

But there's an important distinction that parents don't always consider when choosing a nanny: Being wonderful with children and understanding how children learn and develop are two different skill sets. The very best caregivers bring both.

 

A nanny who understands child development doesn't simply keep children happy, safe, and entertained. They recognize the learning happening in everyday moments, understand the reasons behind children's behavior, and create experiences that support healthy cognitive, social, emotional, and physical growth. Those differences have a meaningful impact on your child's early years.

 

1. Understanding Developmental Milestones: Knowing What Comes Next

 

Children develop at their own pace, but their growth generally follows recognizable patterns. These patterns, often called developmental milestones, help us understand the skills children are developing and how to support them. A caregiver with a foundation in child development understands that milestones extend far beyond learning to walk or talk.

 

They include:

  • Cognitive development: Problem-solving, memory, attention, and early reasoning.

  • Language development: Understanding words, communicating needs, expanding vocabulary, and developing conversational skills.

  • Social-emotional development: Building relationships, recognizing emotions, developing empathy, and learning self-regulation.

  • Physical development: Developing gross motor skills, fine motor coordination, balance, and body awareness.

 

Consider a toddler who repeatedly stacks objects, knocks them down, and starts again. Someone who enjoys children might happily join the game, but a developmentally knowledgeable nanny recognizes that the child is learning cause and effect, spatial relationships, coordination, and early problem-solving. Rather than immediately showing the child the most efficient way to stack objects, the nanny might ask, "I wonder what would happen if we put the big, flat book on the bottom?"

 

That simple interaction encourages the child to think, predict, experiment, and discover. The difference isn't necessarily in the activity. It's in the caregiver's understanding of the learning taking place and their use of developmentally appropriate practice.

 

It's also important to remember that milestones are guides, not deadlines. A knowledgeable caregiver respects differences, notices patterns, and communicates observations with parents without comparing children or attempting to diagnose concerns.

 

2. Responsive Caregiving: It's More Than Meeting Basic Needs

 

Responsive caregiving is one of the foundations of healthy early childhood development. At its heart, responsive caregiving means recognizing a child's signals, interpreting what they may be communicating, and responding consistently, warmly, and appropriately.

 

For infants, this might mean recognizing early signs of hunger, overstimulation, or fatigue.

 

For toddlers, it involves understanding that a meltdown isn't necessarily defiance but a sign that the child is overwhelmed and doesn't have the skills to manage those feelings independently yet.

 

For preschoolers, it might mean recognizing when a child needs encouragement to solve a problem themselves rather than having an adult immediately step in. Imagine a two-year-old becoming frustrated because they can't put on their shoes. A developmentally informed caregiver will see an opportunity to support independence while remaining emotionally available. They could say, "You're working really hard to get that shoe on. It's frustrating when it doesn't work. Would you like me to help you get it started?" This response acknowledges the child's feelings, models language for emotions, supports persistence, and offers assistance without taking away the opportunity to learn.

 

Responsive caregiving doesn't mean allowing children to do whatever they want. It means understanding what children need developmentally and responding in ways that support both emotional security and growing independence.

 

3. Positive Guidance: Understanding What’s Behind the Behavior

 

One of the clearest differences between simply enjoying children and understanding their development becomes apparent during challenging moments. Tantrums. Refusing to share. Difficulty with transitions. Constantly saying "no." These behaviors can be frustrating, but they are often connected to skills children are still developing. Young children lack the impulse control, emotional regulation, communication abilities, or perspective-taking skills adults have.

 

A developmentally informed caregiver understands that behavior is often a form of communication, so rather than focusing exclusively on stopping an unwanted behavior, they ask: What is this child trying to communicate? What skill might they be missing? What support do they need to be successful?

 

Imagine a three-year-old grabs a toy from another child. A purely corrective response might be, "That's not nice. Give it back and say you're sorry." A developmentally informed response might sound like: "I can see you really want that truck. Sam is using it right now. I'm not going to let you grab it. Let's ask if you can have a turn when he's finished." This approach maintains a clear boundary while helping the child practice communication, patience, and social problem-solving.

 

Positive guidance is not an absence of consequences. It involves setting consistent, appropriate limits while teaching children the skills they need to manage their behavior over time. The goal isn't simply to produce immediate compliance. It's to help children develop the skills that eventually allow them to make thoughtful choices independently.

 

4. Age-Appropriate Expectations: Meeting Children Where They Are

 

Sometimes adults unintentionally expect more from children than their developmental abilities allow. We may expect a toddler to share willingly, a preschooler to sit quietly for extended periods, or a young child to regulate strong emotions without adult support.

 

But developmental readiness matters. A caregiver who understands early childhood development knows that expectations should be based on a child's abilities, temperament, experiences, and developmental stage—not simply their chronological age.

 

Here are a few examples:

 

Age

Developmentally informed expectations

Infants

(0–12 months)

Need responsive interactions, safe exploration, and considerable adult support for regulation.

Toddlers

(1–3 years)

Are developing independence, language, and impulse control. Big feelings and difficulty sharing are common.

Preschoolers

(3–5 years)

Are building cooperative play, emotional awareness, and problem-solving skills, but still need guidance and practice.

Early school-age

(5–8 years)

Are gaining independence, attention, and self-regulation, though expectations must remain individualized.

 

These are broad developmental patterns, not rules that apply to every child. For example, expecting a two-year-old to consistently share toys without adult assistance may create unnecessary frustration for everyone involved. A knowledgeable nanny recognizes that parallel play, turn-taking with support, and emerging social awareness are part of the developmental journey. Instead of insisting on an ability the child hasn't fully developed, they provide opportunities to practice it.

 

That's how meaningful learning happens.

 

5. The Everyday Moments That Become Learning Opportunities

 

One of the most valuable things about a developmentally knowledgeable nanny is that they don't need elaborate lesson plans, expensive educational toys, or a packed activity schedule to support learning. They understand that young children learn through relationships, play, exploration, repetition, and meaningful everyday experiences.

 

Consider how much learning can happen during an ordinary day:

  • Preparing a snack: Counting, sequencing, vocabulary, and fine motor coordination.

  • Taking a nature walk: Scientific thinking, sensory exploration, and language development.

  • Building with blocks: Spatial reasoning, problem-solving, creativity, and persistence.

  • Reading together: Vocabulary, comprehension, emotional connection, and early literacy.

  • Playing “pretend”: Imagination, social understanding, communication, and flexibility.

  • Cleaning up toys: Classification, sequencing, responsibility, and following directions.

 

Further, even unstructured, child-led play offers remarkable opportunities for development.  You can read more about the benefits of child-led play here: Your Child Doesn't Need More Activities. They Need More Meaningful Play.  When children have the freedom to explore their own interests, make choices, encounter manageable challenges, and experiment with ideas, they practice important skills that support future learning.

 

The knowledgeable caregiver doesn't need to direct every moment. Instead, they know when to observe, when to ask a thoughtful question, when to introduce a new possibility, and when to simply let the child lead. This balance is especially important. Children need opportunities to discover what they're capable of without an adult constantly providing answers or directing outcomes.

 

6. What Parents Should Look for When Hiring a Nanny

 

When interviewing potential nannies, it's natural to focus on experience, personality, availability, and whether the caregiver seems like a good fit. But parents can also gain valuable insight by asking questions that reveal how a candidate understands and supports children's development. Rather than asking, "Do you have experience with toddlers?" for example, consider asking questions that explore their thinking.

 

Five Questions to Ask a Potential Nanny

1.     How would you respond to a toddler having a tantrum?

Listen for emotional awareness, calm boundaries, and developmentally appropriate expectations.

 

2.     What does a typical day caring for a three-year-old look like?

Look for a balance of play, movement, exploration, rest, and responsive routines.

 

3.     How do you encourage independence without creating frustration?

Strong answers recognize when to offer support and when to allow children to try.

 

4.     How do you handle challenging behaviors like hitting or refusing to share?

Listen for positive guidance, consistent limits, and an understanding of emerging skills.

 

5.     How do you recognize and support a child's developmental progress?

Look for thoughtful observation, individualized activities, and open communication with parents.

 

Parents should also listen for examples rather than just reassuring statements. A candidate who says, "I believe in positive discipline," may have a wonderful philosophy. But asking them to describe how they handled a difficult situation can reveal how that philosophy translates into actual caregiving.

 

Formal education can provide a strong foundation, but a degree alone doesn't guarantee excellent caregiving. Likewise, caregivers without formal degrees can develop substantial knowledge through training, mentorship, and experience. The most important question is whether the nanny can apply developmentally appropriate practices thoughtfully and consistently.

 

The Everly Nannies Perspective

 

At Everly Nannies, we believe exceptional childcare requires more than finding someone who loves children. It requires understanding the whole child. Our approach is shaped by something that makes Everly different: a foundation in early childhood education.

 

Everly was founded by Cera Parrino, an experienced early childhood educator with 22 years of experience as a nanny, teacher, preschool director, consultant, and instructional coach. That experience has included working directly with children, supporting educators, evaluating childcare professionals, and helping create environments where children can thrive.

 

Our comprehensive 23-point vetting process, the Everly 23, helps us look beyond a résumé. We consider a candidate's experience, qualifications, caregiving philosophy, professional judgment, and compatibility with a family's individual needs. We want to understand how a nanny interacts with children, how they approach challenging situations, and whether their expectations align with children's developmental abilities.

 

We also recognize that no two children are alike. A nanny who is an excellent match for an active preschooler may not be the right fit for an infant or a child who needs additional developmental support.

 

Our goal isn't simply to fill a childcare position. It's to help families find caregivers who can build meaningful relationships with their children while supporting their individual growth, interests, and emerging abilities.

 

At Everly Nannies, we believe the right caregiver should offer your child warmth, security, meaningful connection, and opportunities to thrive.  Discover our personalized, developmentally informed approach to nanny placement for Ohio families.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page